BootsnAll Travel Community
BnA Home
BootsnAll Travel Forums
Travel Forums
Talking About Travel
Travel Writing
Will you critique my story?
BootsnAll Travel Forums
Travel Forums
Talking About Travel
Travel Writing
Will you critique my story?Page 1 2
|
Go
![]() |
New
![]() |
Search
![]() |
Notify
![]() |
Tools
![]() |
Reply
![]() |
|
|
Holds PhD in Packing |
Hi All-
So my friend and I are co-writing a book and I started writing bits and pieces here and there. My friends really like it and think I am talented but I wanted to hear some non-biased opinions. ANd since I really respect everybody here and think we all have similar passions and tastes...I thought I'd see what you think. Do I have any talent? Do you like it? Etc. So here it is below. Keep in my I'm the Corporate America girl who started the "where should I go" topic in the member forum. STORY She couldn’t believe what he had just said. Were those words really coming from his mouth? This man, whom she looked up to. He had everything she had always wanted: money, power, a glamorous title, a great Manhattan apartment and a car. But then the words, “I don’t want to hire another woman. What if she gets pregnant and leaves.” Nicole knew she shouldn’t be eavesdropping, but she couldn’t help it. Everybody listens in everywhere in corporate America. Otherwise it wouldn’t be called the rat race. Nicole almost fell over in her seat as she listened. She wanted to scream at him or grab the swingline stapler and staple his head to the desk; whichever came first. One more corporate role model down the drain, she thought to herself as she pretended to tap on her keyboard just lightly enough that she could hear everything being said. Nicole knew the group that Chuck was hiring for. Two of her close female co-worker friends are in the commodities group. It’s true that a third female in the group recently announced her pregnancy. But why should that make a difference? Why should a completely qualified woman be denied a job because she might in the very far away future get pregnant? That was the dumbest thing Nicole had ever heard. Talk about judging a book by it’s cover, there wasn’t even a cover there yet to be judged. Nicole had met the woman they were thinking of hiring and thought she was perfect for the job. But instead another uptight ex-prep school yuppy boy who always got all the breaks in life will get yet another. The thought of being trapped in this life made Nicole sick to her stomach yet again. She felt like running away that instant. But where to? She thought about moving to San Francisco and starting a health food store. She could get her eyebrow pierced again, wear long flowing hippy skirts, listen to Phish and the Dead all day long and bathe once a week. No, that idea was ridiculous, she’d bathe at least 3 times a week. There are people that do that kind of stuff, so why couldn’t she? Maybe she’d meet her lover one day. He would walk into the store, with his long, lean muscular body dressed in a long distance bicyclist’s outfit. He’d smile at Nicole as if they were the only two in the room, unstrap his fanny pack and kindly ask her to recommend her favorite power bars. From that day on they would be inseparable. They would spend weekends on bike trips or hiking remote mountainous trails. They would tell their parents they were going plan a nice traditional wedding, then one day up and elope in Antigua. Do people go to Antigua to elope? Well, maybe not Antiqua but some cool sounding remote island were weddings are conducted. They would honeymoon in Nepal of course, learning to become one with the universe and one with eachother. During this period, they would befriend a Sherpa and train profusely for an Everest climb that upcoming May…. Wait, who was she kidding? That would never happen. Even if she did the most impractical thing and actually had the guts to leave her job and head west, there was still no chance she would romantically meet a young hot bicyclist. Fist of all, he would be repulsed by her double chin and small beady eyes. Second of all, when he asked her to recommend a favorite power bar, she’d probably react with something stupid such as, “Actually, I’m allergic to nuts so I can’t eat power bars because the label says they are manufactured in a peanut prevalent environment”. |
||
|
|
Armchair Traveler |
Your writing is pretty good. I must after having read a few of your other posts it sounds some what like a personal journal transfused into fiction, which is always interesting to read. The theme of letting every thing go for happiness is a rather constant one at BnA and through out modern 20 something culture. If you are interested you should check out Chuck Palahniuk's Invisible Monsters. It really helped to inspire me to take that final frightening step to happiness. And of course there is Fight Club too, but everyone knows about that.
Peace and love, -Ian |
|||
|
|
Forum Whore |
Unbiased opinions, huh? Should I be like Simon Cowell from American Idol?
You definitely have a good rhythm with what you posted. I'm curious as what exactly is it leading to. (Perhaps a mere title would have solved this.) While your writing style is a pleasure to read, I'd have to say that the idea is pretty clichéd. Not that there's anything wrong with it. But such dreams are very common amongst women stuck in cubicle jobs, huh? Clichéd ideas need to jump out to an editor...if publication is what you're aiming for here. Is this the beginnings of an auto-biography? e. http://www.theglobaltrip.com |
|||
|
Wondering Wanderer![]() |
Maybe you can have a twist in this story or a surprise ending... currently it sounds too routine and a tad predictable. But the flow is real good.
|
|||
|
|
Holds PhD in Packing |
Thanks for the constructive criticism. I'm glad you enjoy my writing style...it gives me hope that i actually might be good at this stuff. In terms of the story being cliche or predictible...well, this was just a sample that I had written just to get going. Nothing happens in it really, so I don't really get how it can be predictible. I haven't even come up with a plot yet. Basically my friend and I are writing a lot of shorts seperately and then we are going to come up with a book about the stories of 2 women whose lives become interwined in some way (not sure how yet). And yes, it is a bit autobiographical, but they always say write what you know, right?
If you have any ideas for interesting plot twists or a good idea for the story in general, then please send them my way! thanks |
|||
|
Armchair Traveler![]() |
So is anyone else interested in doing critique/editing exchange for travel stories? I have a couple of pieces up on bootsnall and other places and would love to have people read & reply about content/storyline, as well as writing style, grammar, etc.
I’d be happy to do the same for others in exchange... ~~*---www.majink.org/trav---*~~ |
|||
|
|
Forum Whore |
|
|||
|
Knows What a Schengen Visa Is![]() |
Speaking of stories on this site...ANT do you remember me???....
|
|||
|
|
Lost in Place |
I would love to be included in a little online writing group. Problem is I don't really have anything written right now. But feel free to email me and maybe it will help motivate me.
ktawolf@excite.com |
|||
|
|
Forum Whore |
Hey kt, great idea. That's what these forums are supposed to be...use them wisely!
If you care to "be motivated," you can read my stories here at BootsnAll: http://www.bootsnall.com/bio/etrinidad.shtml My latest one is "Whiz Wit," which I've also pitched around to some travel magazines. Let me take the opportunity here to say THANK YOU BOOTSNALL! My work was discovered on BootsnAll, and it landed me a weekly travelogue column at Lycos Asia: http://travel.lycosasia.com/travelogues Motivated enough, kt? e. http://www.theglobaltrip.com |
|||
|
|
Lost in Place |
Yeah, I'll have to get working. Thanks for the links. kt
|
|||
|
Armchair Traveler![]() |
Alrighty, here are some of my links-- hey, should we just stick to critiqueing Bootsnall stuff or things we've published on other sites?
http://www.bootsnall.com/europetravelguides/swiss/index.shtml http://www.bootsnall.com/travelogues/maj/1.shtml Should critiques be posted here or sent directly to the author? I'm zoning out at work this week so I'll try and do some critiquing. myself... ~~*---www.majink.org/trav---*~~ |
|||
|
|
Moderator Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary (Moderator) |
Hi Jen102,
The topic seems to have shifted a bit, but if you're still interested in a little friendly criticism, then here are a few of my thoughts. As an exercise as you described it, I think it is a wonderful start. You're getting your ideas out on paper (or computer bits as the case may be) and that's the first start. I've written countless stories in my head and, oddly enough, those haven't sold. Its the ones put into concrete fashion that do. So, in this regard, keep that up. As far as what is written currently, it does come across autobiographically and probably because of that ventures a little into stream-of-consciousness. A large portion of the sentences are fragments, yet the second paragraph stretches on for an eternity. I would work on fleshing out the prose and break up the thoughts into paragraphs, rather than fragments. I think it will make it easier to read. Of course, this is a style issue and it is certainly true that there are many professional writers out there who use all manner of fragments and informal grammer, but I'd get the fundamentals down first before you deviate. These are just a few of my thoughts. Again, I think its a terrific beginning. I hope this helps. Shawn |
|||
|
|
Forum Whore |
Maj, FYI: I'm about to leave for a couple of days, so I probably won't be able to get reading your stuff until next week...don't think I'm ignoring!
Everyone else can critique your work in the meantime! e. http://www.theglobaltrip.com |
|||
|
|
Holds PhD in Packing |
thanks for the critique. About the sentence fragments...I guess I was going for an Ernest Hemingway style. But I tend to be very long winded so I should probably work on that.
More to come... |
|||
|
|
Moderator Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary (Moderator) |
Jen102,
Hemingway is a great example. He loved using sentence fragments and I think its safe to say that most would agree he is one of the greatest of American writers. His prose, although simple, is effective and compelling. No doubt there's plenty of room for opinion. Just work to make your writing the best it can be...let the critics decide who to compare it to. Shawn |
|||
|
|
Holds PhD in Packing |
Hi all, just came across this topic. I'd love to be included in the writing group, and will start critiquing the stories listed already in this topic. I personally don't have anything up on BnA as yet, but could get some of my writing together for ya'll to check out as well. Maj and e, looking forward to reading ya'lls work! Jen, great start -- just develop the idea some more, and like others said, try to find a unique twist.
www.2girls1world.com. The journey begins 9.15.03. |
|||
|
|
Forum Whore |
hi k10!
Get some stuff together and join the club! I'm actually working with Maj over instant messenger, bouncing ideas and edits over as we write away. I'm meeting Jen102 tonight for drinks and a writer's brainstorming session. If you haven't seen, my stories are at: http://www.theglobaltrip.com Maj's stories are here: http://www.majink.org So when's your RTW site going to be ready? e. http://www.theglobaltrip.com |
|||
|
Armchair Traveler![]() |
Yah! The more the better. I have to say that having someone to review stuff has really been encouraging-- I usually take forever to get back to an article after the first write. IM and email makes it really fast too-- no waiting 4 weeks for an editor to reply "well, it's OK, but not great" and not tell you what they didnt like about it!
I'm usually online from 10ish-4ish East Coast time, but maybe we could have a virtual meeting at a set time-- either here or on AIM or IRC or whatever. Anyway, I'm free to review more stuff, so send me or post links... -maj ---www.majink.org--- |
|||
|
|
Holds PhD in Packing |
Hey guys, I'll get some stuff together and send it your way. My AIM is k10texas as well, so feel free to add me and send me a message anytime! I'm gonna start reading over stuff tonight and will get back to ya'll with my thoughts. How fun!
www.2girls1world.com. The journey begins 9.15.03. |
|||
|
| Previous Topic | Next Topic | powered by eve community | Page 1 2 |
| Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|
BnA Home
BootsnAll Travel Forums
Travel Forums
Talking About Travel
Travel Writing
Will you critique my story?
BootsnAll Travel Forums
Travel Forums
Talking About Travel
Travel Writing
Will you critique my story?© BootsnAll.com 1999-2008.











